How do you run a competitive pitch between AI design agencies?
Give every firm the same brief, the same deadline, and the same access to your team. Ask for an approach, not free design work: how they would research the problem, what they would prototype first, and how they would measure success. Set evaluation criteria before proposals arrive, and score each proposal against them. Share the same background materials and a single point of contact, give every firm equal time to ask questions, and compare proposals side by side.
A short paid discovery phase shows how a team works better than unpaid spec work. Punchcut’s Spark Sessions, short workshops that define the opportunity, serve that purpose and lead into Product Delivery if the fit is right. The services page explains each model. For criteria to borrow, see Punchcut’s UX agency comparison, then get in touch.